A wave of new investors always brings a wave of people who want their money. With record numbers of first-time investors opening accounts, the scams have grown with them. They rely on you being new, excited and a little afraid of missing out. All of them fail against a few simple checks.
1. The pump and dump
- Accumulate. Organisers quietly buy a small, thinly traded stock over weeks.
- Promote. 'Jackpot script', 'operator-backed', 'target Rs. 80 in ten days' — pushed in Telegram and WhatsApp groups, YouTube videos and paid posts. Early screenshots of real gains make it convincing.
- Pump. Followers pile in. With so few shares available, the price hits upper cap day after day. This is the proof the group points to.
- Dump. The organisers sell everything to the incoming buyers. Buying stops, the price locks at lower cap, and there is nobody to sell to — sometimes for weeks.
Signs you are looking at one: a small company you have never heard of; volume suddenly many times its normal level; a string of upper caps; no announcement on PSX explaining it; a target price and a deadline; and great urgency.
2. Fake brokers and fake apps
Fraudsters copy the names, logos and even the staff photos of real brokerage houses. They run professional-looking apps and websites showing your 'portfolio' growing nicely. You deposit, the numbers go up, you deposit more. When you try to withdraw there is a 'tax', a 'clearance fee', then silence. The app was only ever a display — no shares were bought.
3. 'Let me manage your account'
A friendly 'analyst' or 'fund manager' offers to trade your account for a share of profits, or asks you to send money to invest on your behalf, or wants your login. Managing other people's money requires a licence from SECP, and legitimate managers do not operate from personal bank accounts or chat apps.
4. Guaranteed returns
'5% a month, guaranteed, backed by PSX trading.' No share investment can guarantee a return, and anything promising several percent a month is describing a Ponzi scheme: early investors are paid with later investors' deposits until the money stops coming in.
5. Paid signals and courses
Not all are frauds, and learning is good. But ask one question: if these signals reliably made money, why would the seller need your Rs. 5,000 subscription? Screenshots are trivially edited, and nobody posts their losing trades.
The checks that stop all of it
| Before you | Check |
|---|---|
| Open an account | The firm is on PSX's official list of brokers, and the app or website matches the address published there |
| Send money | The bank account is in the brokerage firm's name — never a person's, never a wallet number |
| Trust your balance | CDC is sending you its own SMS and email alerts, and your holdings appear when you log in to CDC directly |
| Act on a tip | There is an announcement on PSX that explains the move, and the stock trades in real volume |
| Hand over control | Never share your password, PIN or OTP with anyone, for any reason |
| Believe a promise | Guaranteed returns do not exist in shares. Walk away. |
Why smart people fall for these
Because the scam is designed around emotion, not logic. Urgency ('only today'), social proof ('2,000 members are in'), authority ('ex-fund manager'), and above all an early win — the first small tip often works, or the first small withdrawal is paid promptly, precisely so that you commit more.
Try it on StockPulseCheck whether there is real newsNext time you are sent a 'hot' stock, look it up here first. No announcement and thin volume is your answer.